Background: Acne in women is often associated with anxiety and depression, and may persist from adolescence as well as manifest for the first time in adulthood. Genetic and hormonal factors contribute to its etiopathogenesis, and maintenance treatment is required, usually for years, due to its clinical evolution.
Objective: To develop a guide for the clinical practice of adult female acne.
Methods: A team of five experts with extensive experience in acne conducted a literature review of the main scientific evidence and met to discuss the best practices and personal experiences to develop a guide containing recommendations for the clinical practice of adult female acne.
Results: The group of specialists reached consensus on the main guidelines for clinical practice, providing detailed recommendations on clinical picture, etiopathogenesis, laboratory investigation and treatment of adult female acne.
Conclusion: Different from teenage acne, adult female acne presents some characteristics and multiple etiopathogenic factors that make its management more complex. This guide provides recommendations for best clinical practices and therapeutic decisions. However, the authors consider that additional studies are needed in order to provide more evidence for adult female acne to be better understood.
Acne affects an increasing number of adult females, impairing quality of life, with significant negative psychological effect and social impact. Adult female acne (AFA) is defined as one that affects women over the age of 25 and may persist continuously or intermittently from adolescence or manifest for the first time in this period. It is believed that genetic and hormonal factors contribute to the pathogenesis of AFA, characterized by chronic evolution, requiring maintenance treatment, in some cases for years.1-4
In 1979, a publication showed that acne in adults over 18 years of age was relatively common, persisting in 5% of females between the ages of 40 and 49.5 Only in 1997 did acne in adults, older than 25 years of age, begin to gain more attention, showing that 76% of these patients were women with a mean age of 35.5 years. Most of the cases were from persistent acne and only 18.4% of females had late acne, starting after 25 years, mainly due to hyperandrogenism changes.3 Other studies have confirmed that persistent acne is more common than acne beginning in adulthood.6,7
Other authors have confirmed that adult females are more affected than men in all age groups and that acne can persist even after 50 years of age.
In addition to persistent and late acne, more recently a third type has been suggested, called recurrent acne, that is present in adolescence, improves for a variable period of time, and returns in adulthood. There are few publications regarding this, because current researches, despite questioning the age of onset of acne, rarely ask the patient if acne recurred after a period in adolescence.8 Some authors suggest two categories of AFA: 25 to 44 years of age and over 45 years of age in the period near menopause, but the characteristics of each group still need to be better defined.9
Clinical ConditionThe first studies showed that the AFA lesions were located mainly on the lower part of the face, including the mandibular region, the perioral region and the chin, conferring a U-shape, in addition to the anterior cervical region. It is characterized by inflammatory lesions, papules and pustules, of mild to moderate intensity, with the presence of few closed comedones or microcysts. Postinflammatory hyperpigmentation is common and scars can occur in 20% of affected women.10 In addition, the skin may be more sensitive than that of adolescents, with less tolerance to topical medications.8,11Table 1 demonstrates two clinical forms of AFA, according to the classification of Preneau and Dreno.8
Clinical forms of adult female acne
| CLINICAL FORM | CHARACTERISTICS | PRODUCTION OF SEBUM |
|---|---|---|
| Inflammatory(affects 58% of females) | Papules, pustules and nodules that lead to the formation of scars | Increased seborrhea is not always present |
| Retentional | Numerous open comedones and microcysts; small number of inflammatory lesions | Increased seborrhea is always present and lesions appear all over the face |
Recently, the classic AFA location on the lower third of the face was questioned.9 Studies have observed cases with localization on other areas of the face and back. One study showed that most women (89.8%) had involvement of multiple facial areas, such as the forehead, malar region, mandibular area and temporal region, with a similar severity spectrum to adolescents. The most common clinical presentation was mixed facial acne, with noninflammatory and inflammatory lesions. The majority of the women (93.7%) had comedones, and 48.4% presented lesions on the trunk and only 11.2% on the mandibular regions.1
Severity scalesIt is believed that AFA is different from juvenile acne due to its clinical evolution.12 Scales have been developed to validate a severity score for each type of acne and thus ensure the best treatment. These include the GEA (Global Evaluation Acne) scale and, more recently, the AFAST (Adult Female Acne Scoring Tool), which includes the submandibular region evaluation, as shown in table 2.12,13
AFAST rating scale for adult female acne
| AFAST SCALE (Adult Female Acne Scoring Tool) | ||
|---|---|---|
| Score 1: Assess the severity of acne on face (GEA SCORE) | ||
| 0 | No acne lesions or almost no lesions | Residual pigmentation or erythema |
| 1 | Almost no lesions | Few open or closed comedones - Few papules |
| 2 | Mild | Less than half of the face involved - Few comedones, papules and pustules |
| 3 | Moderate | More than half of the face involved - Numerous papules, pustules, comedones and up to a nodule |
| 4 | Severe | Entire face - Numerous papules, pustules, comedones and rare nodules |
| 5 | Very Severe | Very inflammatory on the entire face, with nodules |
| Score 2: Assess the severity of acne in the submandibular zone | ||
| 0 | No lesions - Erythema and postinflammatory hyperpigmentation | |
| 1 | Rare papules, pustules and/or comedones | |
| 2 | Few papules, pustules and/or comedones - Less than 25% of the affected area - A nodule/cyst may be present | |
| 3 | Numerous papules, pustules and/or comedones and at least 25% of the affected area - Two or more nodules/cysts | |
The etiopathogenesis of acne vulgaris involves a complex interaction between the main factors such as: genetic predisposition; androgenic hormone stimulation leading to an increase in sebaceous secretion; alteration of the lipid composition; follicular hyperkeratinization; bacterial colonization mainly by Propionibacterium acnes (P. acnes) and periglandular dermal inflammation.14 Currently, inflammation is considered a key component and can be detected on histopathological and immunohistochemical examination in apparently non-inflammatory acneic lesions such as comedones and even in perilesional areas, without lesions (subclinical) .15,16
The causes of AFA have not yet been fully elucidated. Several other factors have been postulated as triggers or aggravating factors, such as: exposure to ultraviolet radiation, stress, obesity, diet, smoking, sleep disorders, cosmetics, medications, excessive skin washing, possible resistance to P. acnes and endocrine deficiency diseases.1 Currently, the deficiency of the epidermal barrier function has also been reported as a relevant change. The damage of the barrier and the consequent increase in transepidermal water loss may be responsible for the onset of the inflammatory cascade that constitutes the central change in the onset of acne.17,18Figure 1 presents the main etiopathogenical factors in AFA.
Genetic predisposition has been considered an important predisposing factor, influencing the number, size and activity of the sebaceous glands. Its influence on hormonal control has also been observed, as well as on the process of follicular hyperkeratinization and on innate immunity. In one study, adult women with acne reported first-degree relatives with acne in adulthood.19
HormonesThe role of androgens in the etiopathogenesis of acne vulgaris is well established. Testosterone, Dehydroepiandrosterone Sulfate (SDHEA) and Dihydrotestosterone (DHT) stimulate sebaceous gland growth and sebum production. Estrogens have the opposite effect, that is, they inhibit the secretion of androgens, modulate genes involved in the growth of the sebaceous gland and inhibit their function. The activity of the sebaceous gland therefore depends on the estrogen/androgen ratio.20
In relation to AFA and hormones, the following are outstanding:
1) Increased sensitivity of the sebaceous gland to androgenic hormones: As in acne vulgaris, in AFA there is an increase in the number and sensitivity of the receptors located in sebocytes and keratinocytes to circulating androgenic hormones.
2) Increased peripheral hormonal conversion: sebocytes and keratinocytes present an enzymatic system capable of locally producing testosterone and DHT. Hyperactivity and abnormal activity of enzymes related to the metabolism of androgenic hormones such as 5-alpha reductase, 3-beta-hydroxysteroid dehydrogenase and 17-hydroxysteroid dehydrogenase, with increased pre-hormone peripheral conversion (SDHEA, androstenedione and testosterone) into more potent androgenic hormones (testosterone and DHT). DHT is 5 to 10 times more potent than its precursor, testosterone, and less likely to be metabolized by aromatase into estrogen.20
3) Worsening of the disease in the premenstrual period in 60 to 70% of women, as well as in premenopausal, pregnancy and during the use of progestin-only contraceptives. In these periods there is a relative increase of the hormones with greater androgenic activity, in relation to estradiol.
4) Other hormones, besides androgens and estrogens, regulate the production of sebum: the sebaceous gland is a neuroendocrine organ and the production of sebum can also be stimulated, in periods of stress, by neuropeptides and hormones such as melanocortins and corticotropin-releasing hormone (CRH).21 CRH increases the expression of 3 β-hydroxy-steroid dehydrogenase mRNA, the enzyme responsible for the conversion of dihydroepiandrosterone (DHEA) to testosterone. Also neuropeptides, histamine, retinoids, vitamin D and insulin-like growth factor 1 (IGF-1) have been described as regulators of sebum production.
Changes in sebumQualitative changes were verified in the components of sebum in the skin with acne. There is a relative decrease of Linoleic Acid (AL), an Essential Fatty Acid (EFA), protector of the glandular epithelial wall. There is also the peroxidation of squalene by the combined action of P. acnes and ultraviolet radiation. These alterations and the presence of free fatty acids resulting from the hydrolysis of triglycerides, through the action of lipases released by P. acnes, cause damage the epithelium, increasing infundibular keratinization and dermal inflammation.14
Follicular hyperkeratinizatinThere is an abnormal proliferation of keratinocytes, stimulated by pro-inflammatory cytokines, such as interleukin-1 alpha (IL-1 alpha). This cytokine is triggered by the activation of Toll-like receptors or TLR 2 and 4, related to innate immunity, which recognize molecular patterns present in P. acnes, as well as sebaceous hyper-secretion and squalene peroxidation.14 The formation of the micro-comedone is also preceded by a mononuclear infiltrate formed mainly by CD4+ T lymphocytes and CD68+ macrophages, which corroborates to the hypothesis of the participation of the inflammatory process in the early stages of acne.22
Bacterial colonizationThe main bacterium involved in the pathogenesis of acne is P. acnes. It is a Gram-positive anaerobic bacterium that makes up the microbiome of the skin, being located preferably in the seborrheic areas. In skin with acne there is an exaggerated growth of the population of P. acnes.23P. acnes is involved in several mechanisms: stimulation of follicular hyper-keratinization; alteration of the sebaceous composition; and inflammatory response through TLR activation. In addition, it produces several enzymes, such as lipases, proteases, hyaluronidases, endoglyceramidase, sialidase/neuroaminidase, proteinase and 5 cAMP factors, which contribute to follicular rupture and tissue degradation.24
Immuno-inflammatory processesUpon recognition of the P. acnes molecular patterns, TLR 2 and 4 are activated, triggering an inflammatory cascade through the nuclear pathway NFk β, with production of pro-inflammatory cytokines or interleukins and tumor necrosis factor alpha (TNF-alpha) that recruit neutrophils and macrophages, maintaining the inflammatory cycle. Activation of TLR leads to the release of antimicrobial peptides such as beta-defensins 1 and 2, cathelecidins and granulolysins. A second nuclear pathway is also activated - pathway AP1, with release of metalloproteinases 1, 3 and 9 that degrade the extracellular dermal matrix and are associated with the formation of scars.25
Other factorsDietStudies have shown that consumption of high glycemic and dairy foods increases insulin and IGF1 levels. The gonads and sebaceous glands have receptors for both hormones which stimulate the production of androgens, such as testosterone, and inhibit the action of aromatase that converts testosterone to estradiol. The nutritional status of the cell is recognized initially by the transcription factors FOX01 and the signaling pathway mTORC1.26 High glycemic load foods, dairy products, increased insulin and IGF1 stimulate mTORC1, triggering processes such as: increased protein and lipid synthesis, cell proliferation, cell differentiation with acroinfundibular hyper-proliferation of keratinocytes, sebaceous gland hyperplasia, increased sebaceous lipogenesis, insulin resistance and increased body mass index.26 In addition to the diet rich in foods with a high glycemic load and the consumption of dairy products, worsening of acne by the use of dietary supplements for muscle mass gains that are rich in branched-chain amino acids and peptides derived from whey is observed in daily practice.27
DrugsCertain medications are associated with the development of acne, such as benzodiazepines, lithium, cyclosporin, ramipril, isoniazid, iodides, bromides, vitamin B-type complexes, serotonin uptake inhibitors, epidermal growth receptor inhibitors and progestin contraceptives.28-30 First-generation progestins such as norgestrel and levonorgestrel have androgenic effect similar to testosterone.31 Corticosteroids stimulate hyperkeratinization and increase the expression of TLR 2.28
Authors have noted that levonorgestrel intrauterine devices, subcutaneous etonorgestrel and levonorgestrel implants, and long-acting methods with progestin alone may have a negative effect on acne or may trigger acne in predisposed women.32-34 A prospective study showed that 10% of 80 women who used subcutaneous implants with etonorgestrel had acne.33 Another multicenter, randomized, controlled study of subcutaneous implants with etonorgestrel or levonorgestrel compared to copper intrauterine devices showed that acne was more frequent in the group with implants.34 However, it is important to consider other causes for the appearance of acne in these cases, such as the suspension of estrogen-containing oral contraceptives.32
StressStress stimulates the release of pro-inflammatory cytokines and CRH, leading to increased levels of cortisol. Recent studies show that sleep deprivation associated with women’s modern lifestyle and stress have an important impact on the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis and in increased secretion of stress-related hormones, and may also be an aggravating factor for acne.21 Goulden et al3 and Poli et al35 reported stress as a worsening factor for acne in 71% and 50% of women, respectively.
TobaccoThere is a close relationship between smoking and the occurrence of AFA.36 Studies show that tobacco is the main factor responsible for the appearance of non-inflammatory acne in this age group, with a significant difference between female smokers and nonsmokers. The comedonal form predominates in smokers and is characterized by the presence of micro and macro-comedones and few inflammatory lesions, which led the authors to describe this clinical form as “smoker’s face.” The sebaceous gland is sensitive to acetylcholine that is stimulated by nicotine. Acetylcholine leads to cellular modulation and differentiation, inducing hyper-keratinization and influencing sebum production and composition, as well as reducing antioxidant agents and increasing peroxidation of sebum components, such as squalene.36
Endocrine diseasesThe association of acne with an endocrinopathy characterized by hyper-androgenism usually presents other clinical signs such as: hirsutism, seborrhoea, alopecia, menstrual disorders, ovulatory dysfunction, infertility, early puberty, metabolic syndrome and virilization.37 The main endocrinopathies that occur with hyper-androgenism are: Polycystic ovary syndrome POS, late congenital adrenal hyperplasia or disfunction and, more rarely, ovarian, adrenal, pituitary and hypothalamic tumors.37
Hyperinsulinemia and peripheral insulin resistance occur frequently in women with POS. Hyperinsulinemia influences the concentration of plasma IGF-1 and Insulin Growth Factor Binding Protein-Like 3 binding protein (IGFBP-3), which act directly on keratinocyte proliferation and apoptosis. In a hyperinsulinemic state, the rate of IGF-1 is elevated and IGFBP-3 is lowered, leading to an imbalance that culminates in hyperproliferation of keratinocytes. Increased IGF-1 also inhibits aromatase and prevents the conversion of testosterone to estrogen. In this hyperinsulinemia, there is still a decrease in the hepatic production of SHBG, favoring the elevation of the free androgens that constitute its active form.37 In adult women with acne and POS, it is important to evaluate the possibility of glucose intolerance. In POS, total cholesterol is increased at the expense of increasing the low density lipoprotein (LDL) fraction and decreasing the high density lipoprotein (HDL). Triglycerides are also increased as the plasminogen activator inhibitor (PAI) is. These changes in lipids and the increase in PAI favor arterial hypertension, coronary disease and thrombosis.37 In women with acne, obesity and PCOS, metabolic syndrome is very common, characterized by: 1) abdominal obesity (circumference of the waist)> 88cm; 2) triglycerides> 150mg / dL; 3) HDL <50mg / dL; 4) blood pressure> 130 /> 85mm Hg; 5) high glycemia = 110-126mg / dL; and glycemia two hours after the glucose tolerance test = 140-199mg / dL.37
Laboratory InvestigationsIn the presence of other clinical signs of hyperandrogenism, most authors suggest plasma concentrations of free and total testosterone, S-DHEA, Luteinizing Hormone (LH), Follicle Stimulating Hormone (FSH) and, in some cases, when suspecting POS, transvaginal ultrasound for visualization of the ovaries. These dosages should always be performed in the follicular phase, preferably between the first and fifth day of the menstrual cycle and the collection should be done in the morning, between 8 and 10 am. In this way, the hormonal variations of the menstrual cycle interfere less with blood analysis. POS is the most frequently diagnosed cause. It is not recommended to perform exams when hormonal contraceptives are in use.37
In suspected POS, the following criteria should be checked: presence of menstrual alterations (amenorrhea or oligomenorrhea), clinical and/or biochemical and/or hyperandrogenism, as well as ultrasonographic changes (presence of 12 or more follicles with 2 and 9 mm of diameter or increase in ovarian volume > 10cm3). In the revised consensus of 2004, the presence of two of the three criteria confirmed the diagnosis.38 However, today the difficulty persists for the standardization of the criteria for its precise diagnosis.39,40Figure 2 presents a scheme for laboratory investigation of AFA.
Although most AFA patients show no signs of clinical or laboratory hyperandrogenism, slightly elevated levels of S-DHEA have been observed.41
DHT could be useful as a primary marker of peripheral androgen production, but its dosage is not recommended in clinical practice, since it is rapidly metabolized and has high affinity for SHBG.42
A distal metabolite of DHT, produced in androgen-responsive tissues, is 3-alpha, 17-beta-androstanediol glucuronate. In the final phase of metabolization, the enzyme 3α-hydroxy dehydrogenase converts DHT to 3α-androstenediol which undergoes glucuronidation. This modification decreases its affinity for binding proteins, increases its hydrophilicity and facilitates renal excretion.43 This metabolite can be used as a marker of hyperandrogenism, especially in women with idiopathic hirsutism, but is not useful in AFA.
Another androgenic metabolite of interest is Androsterone Glucuronate (ADT-G), which corresponds to 93% of all metabolites. Currently the use of sensitive and specific laboratory techniques, such as liquid chromatography associated with mass spectrometry, for the dosages of this metabolite, allows evaluation of the total androgenic activity of the organism, with great accuracy, showing correlation with the clinical findings.44
Treatment Of Adult Female AcneAFA is a therapeutic challenge because it presents a tendency to relapse, even after cycles of oral antibiotics or isotretinoin.3 The typical evolution of AFA, with frequent relapses, makes maintenance treatment essential.45
In choosing the treatment, numerous factors must be taken into account: acne severity, response to previous treatments, psychosocial impact, possibility of pregnancy, slow response to treatment and increased risk of sensitive skin irritation. Individual preferences and costs are also important factors.2,7 In the Brazilian population, the diversity of phototypes, with a large contingent of patients prone to post-inflammatory hyperchromia, as well as climatic variation limit therapeutic options, contributing to their complexity. Figure 3 presents an algorithm for treating AFA.
Topical Treatment
Topical treatments are the most widely used and effective option for treating moderate AFA and for maintenance treatment. Tolerability and efficacy may contribute to greater adherence to treatment, good outcomes, and patient satisfaction.46 Therapeutic regimens employing resources directed against two or more fundamental pathogenic factors are the main strategy in cases of mild to moderate intensity of acne.47
RetinoidsAdapalene: The efficacy and tolerability of adapalene 0.3% compared to the vehicle in women aged 18-41 was evaluated in an analysis of data obtained in two studies. There was a significant reduction at the 12th week (P = 0.045) of the inflammatory lesions (-61%) and non-inflammatory lesions (-51%). The main side effects were dryness and “skin discomfort”.48 The concentration of 0.1% has also been studied with positive results and good tolerance.49
Tretinoin: Increased efficacy of AFA treatment was demonstrated when tretinoin at 0.025% concentration was associated with spironolactone. In that same study, another group used 0.1% adapalene in cream associated with spironolactone with similar results. Other authors have shown improvement in inflammatory acne in adolescents and adults when using topical tretinoin at concentrations of 0.04% to 0.1% in micro-capsulated presentations.50
AntibioticsTopical antibiotics have a direct anti-inflammatory action reducing perifollicular lymphocytic infiltrate. Due to the significant increase of P. acnes strains resistant to clindamycin and erythromycin, the use of these substances alone is contra-indicated.7
Benzoyl peroxideIn adult women, benzoyl peroxide can induce irritative contact dermatitis or skin dryness, the extent of which is related to the amount and type of product, concentration, and vehicle. Therefore, concentrations of benzoyl peroxide above 5% are not recommended for use in adult women.7 It can also cause photosensitivity and bleaching of clothing.
Azelaic acidAzelaic acid 20%, applied twice a day, was evaluated in a study for the treatment of AFA in 241 women, alone or in combination with various treatments (including adapalene, benzoyl peroxide, cosmeceuticals, isotretinoin and oral hormonal contraceptives). The study concluded that topical treatment improved the Dermatology Quality of Life Index (DLQI) and reduced the severity of acne.51 Azelaic Acid 15% gel, applied twice daily, was also effective in reducing post-inflammatory pigmentation.52 There was a significant reduction in the expression of TLR-2 in the skin of adult females with facial acne who used azelaic acid 15% gel or combined oral contraceptive (drospirenone + ethinylestradiol). The authors suggested a possible anti-inflammatory effect of oral contraceptive and azelaic acid in AFA via modulation of this receptor.53
According to the AFA review, published in 2013, azelaic acid (20% cream or 15% gel) is recommended as the first line of treatment in monotherapy for non-inflammatory and inflammatory acne. Azelaic acid shows similar efficacy to other topical therapies in the treatment of mild to moderate acne and is associated with a favorable tolerability profile and high rates of satisfaction.7 Finally, it is unlikely that systemic side effects occur with azelaic acid, making it safe for use during pregnancy and breastfeeding.7 Azelaic acid represents an important option for women of childbearing age and with a desire to become pregnant as it is considered safe by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA).
DapsoneDapsone 5% gel was used as treatment twice daily in black adult females with good efficacy and tolerance. In patients with acne vulgaris, it has been shown to be useful when combined with doxycycline and then alone as maintenance for long periods, with the advantage of having no risk for bacterial resistance.54,55
AssociationsRetinoids + Benzoyl peroxideThe efficacy and safety of adapalene 0.1% combined with 2.5% benzoyl peroxide gel compared to the vehicle in women 25 years of age or older were analyzed by meta-analysis of data extracted from subgroups from three multi-center, phase 2 and 3, randomized, parallel and double-blind studies. A rapid onset of action was demonstrated, with a significant reduction in lesions from the first week of use; the combination was considered effective, safe and tolerated well in both the population under 18 years and over 25 years, with similar indices.46
Retinoids + AntibioticsThe tretinoin-clindamicyn combination has been studied for the treatment of acne; a later analysis included only data from adult females. The combination proved to be more effective in reducing inflammatory and non-inflammatory lesions than the isolated tretinoin or clindamycin or the carrier substance.56
Antibiotics + Benzoyl peroxideThe combination of benzoyl peroxide 3.75% + clindamycin 1.2% was studied for long-term use (up to 24 weeks) in 20 adult females. At week 12, inflammatory lesions decreased by 70% and non-inflammatory lesions decreased by 58%. In the 24th week, the improvement was 93% and 90%, respectively. There were no serious adverse events. This study allowed to evaluate the safety of long-term use as well as demonstrated continuous improvement.57
Systemic TreatmentAntibioticsAdult women with facial acne have a good response to antibiotics; however, relapses are common after discontinuation of treatment. The combination of systemic antibiotics with topical products is recommended because it presents synergistic effects, accelerating the response and reducing the duration of treatment. Tetracycline and its derivatives are the first choice of antibiotics for the treatment of AFA. Second-generation tetracyclins, such as lymecycline, doxycycline and minocycline, are associated with better absorption when ingested with food and better adherence, because of their single daily dose regimen. It should be emphasized that they should not be used during pregnancy as they may cause inhibition of skeletal fetal growth and dental changes. Erythromycin in stearate form can be used during pregnancy and lactation.7,58
Systemic antibiotics should not be used as monotherapy in the treatment of acne for the potential of developing bacterial resistance. Benzoyl peroxide in the concentration of 2.5 to 5% has synergistic action to antibiotics, accelerating the response, besides avoiding the development of resistance. Azelaic acid as well as topical retinoids are alternatives, particularly if there is hyperchromia.7,58
HormonesHormones are highly effective for AFA, even in patients without serum hormone changes, they are suitable for long-term therapy because they have no potential to induce bacterial resistance and represent an alternative to systemic antibiotics. In adult females, hormonal agents are recommended in the following situations: presence of severe seborrhea; worsening in the premenstrual period; presence of endocrine changes; persistent recalcitrant inflammatory acne in which standard treatments have failed, including repeated cycles of isotretinoin and when oral contraception is required or desired. As hormone treatments reduce excess sebum production, it is recommended that they are combined with agents that act on other pathogenic factors, such as antibiotics, benzoyl peroxide, retinoids, and azelaic acid.7,58
Androgen receptor blockersThe most prominent are: cyproterone acetate, spironolactone, drospirenone and flutamide.
Ciproterone acetate: Combined with ethinylestradiol, it is recommended for the treatment of mild to moderate AFA. Side effects include menstrual changes, tenderness and enlargement of the breast, nausea, vomiting, fluid retention, edema, headache, and melasma.7
SPIRONOLACTONE: A study published by Sato et al59, demonstrated efficacy of spironolactone in the treatment of adult females with acne vulgaris. In monotherapy, 80% of the patients present menstrual irregularity.59 A retrospective study of spironolactone found that there is no need for periodic control of potassium levels in young women, who do not have nephropathies, and are not users of other medications that may increase potassium levels.60 The combined use of spironolactone with topical retinoid seems to provide a superior response to the retinoid treatment isolated in AFA.61 Spironolactone can be used to promote androgen blockade in patients using levonorgestrel intrauterine devices or to increase androgen blockade in those who opt for combined oral contraceptive pills (OCPs).62 In these cases, doses of 100 mg daily are safe and rarely associated with side effects.63 A systematic review published in 2017 concluded that the evidence for its use in the treatment of AFA is still poor, its recommendation is still based on expert opinion or consensus, and randomized, controlled, double-blind trials for the proof of effectiveness are still lacking.64
Inhibitors of ovarian androgen productionOCPs containing ethinyl estradiol combined with progestins with antiandrogenic activity are recommended for the treatment of mild to moderate AFA. Although the evidence is limited and somewhat conflicting, combinations containing cyproterone acetate may be slightly more effective than those containing newer progestins, such as desogestrel, gestodene, levonorgestrel, or norgestimate. Drospirenone-containing OCPs are effective in reducing inflammatory and non-inflammatory acne lesions. Clinicians should be aware of the absolute and relative contra-indications of OCPs prior to prescription.7 According to a systematic review in 2014, the risk of thromboembolism with OCPs is related to both estrogen and progestin type. Thus, the higher the estrogen concentration the greater the risk, and for the progestins it was concluded that the second generation (more androgenic) have a lower risk than those of the third and fourth generations.65
Inhibitors of adrenal androgen production
Low doses of corticosteroids, such as prednisone (2.5 or 5mg), can suppress adrenal androgen production and are recommended in late congenital adrenal hyperplasia, acute inflammatory lesions in AFA, and short-term treatment of very severe acne.7
IsotretinoinExcept for severe cases, oral isotretinoin is typically indicated only after failure of conventional treatments. In adult females it may be recommended, with great attention to the elevated risk of teratogenicity, making the adoption of highly effective contraception methods mandatory. If there are no contra-indications, it is the first line for nodulocystic acne and second line for moderate forms not responsive to courses of oral antibiotic always associated with topical medications and frequent recurrences, tendency to scars and negative psychosocial impact.66,67
It acts by reducing the size and activity of the sebaceous glands by apoptosis of sebocytes; exhibits anti-inflammatory properties by modulating TLR 2 expression and gene transcription mediated by Fox O or Forkhead Box Class O.68,69 Due to the multiple mechanisms of action, several off-label indications have already been suggested in the literature such as AFA, rosacea, photo-aging, seborrheic dermatitis, among others.70-74
Its effectiveness is undeniable, but there are side effects. The most common are mucocutaneous: cheilitis, xerophthalmia, conjunctivitis, nasal dryness, epistaxis and irritative dermatitis. Laboratory abnormalities may include elevation of liver enzymes, increase in triglyceride and cholesterol levels, elevation of LDL fraction, and decrease in HDL fraction.75-78 Teratogenicity is the most serious and irreversible adverse effect. Fetal exposure to isotretinoin, regardless of dose, at any time during gestation, but especially in the first trimester, can cause serious defects, with an incidence of approximately 28%.79
The occurrence of depression, suicidal ideation or attempted suicide associated with isotretinoin in the treatment of acne vulgaris has been reported in the literature of case reports and case-control studies. The observed incidence ranges from less than 1% to 3%, while in the general population it is estimated to be between 1.6 and 7.5%, with an average of 3%.80 Numerous studies have concluded that the drug more often determines improvement or cure of depressive symptoms that have been proven to be related to acne and cause depression.81,82 Population studies have not confirmed this association. However, the recommendation remains to monitor symptoms and, if necessary, request psychiatric evaluation and treatment. It is worth remembering that in adult females, emotional and psychic disorders, stress, insomnia, and other symptoms are common.21
The development of Inflammatory Bowel Disease (IBD), particularly ulcerative colitis was related to isotretinoin. However, several population-based, case-control studies have concluded that this association does not exist.83,84 On the other hand, Crohn’s disease has been reported with the use of tetracycline-class antibiotics, particularly doxycycline and even topical treatments for acne, evidencing that the causal factor is the disease and not the therapeutic option.85 There seems to be a misconception about the true triggering factor. A recent meta-analysis has shown that there is no increased risk of developing IBD after exposure to isotretinoin.86
Clinical and laboratory monitoring includes detailed history, complete physical examination, and complementary examinations. Reassessments of hepatic lipids and transaminases were performed monthly in the past. Considering that the proportion of patients with laboratory abnormalities is low, particularly adolescents, it is currently recommended to repeat the tests 4 to 6 weeks after starting treatment and reassessments only for those who have changed.86-88 The recommended daily dose is 0.5 to 1.0mg / kg, after meals (preferably fatty), for a period of 6 to 12 months, up to a total dose of 120 to 150mg/kg.66,67
There are reports of use of lower daily doses, without the need to reach the total dose of 120mg/kg body weight. The benefits of regimens with 0.3 to 0.4mg/kg/day, 20mg/day, 20mg every other day, 5mg/day, in the treatment of moderate acne, with the same efficacy, fewer side effects and greater adherence to treatment.89-91 However, this is not recommended for use in leaflets. These regimens may be a useful option for AFA resistant to topical and hormonal treatments by reducing adverse events. However, effective prevention of pregnancy is necessary since these women may be of childbearing age and the risk of teratogenicity is equal to the use at usual doses.79 To begin treatment in women of childbearing age, it is necessary to inform of the risks, the need for two contraceptive methods, pregnancy tests and to wait for menstruation. In adult females, particularly those with overweight tendency or obese, or with hormonal changes, more frequent laboratory monitoring becomes essential. There has been an increased risk of elevated cholesterol and triglycerides and weight gain.92,93 No changes were detected in serum androgens and insulin.93
Adult women with hyperandrogenism often require more than one course of treatment with isotretinoin, in addition to hormones. One measure that may contribute to avoid recurrence is maintenance therapy with adapalene, benzoyl peroxide, or azelaic acid for 6 months to 2 years.94 A risk of relapse that is 3.5 times greater has been reported in women who did not use concomitant anti-androgen therapy.95
Adjuvant treatmentsCosmeceuticals and cosmeticsThe topical and systemic treatment for acne can cause dryness, irritation, damage to the epidermal barrier, increased transepidermal water loss and inflammation, and may reduce adhesion. Moisturizers may contribute to reduce these adverse events of topical products and oral isotretinoin by avoiding the impairment of the epidermal barrier that is essential to prevent or reduce inflammation.7,96,97
Many authors consider that because cosmeceuticals are available without prescription and medical supervision, there may be harm in educating patients about their dermatoses (such as acne). Intensive advertising is highly targeted at adult females and may induce them to self-medication with ineffective and skin-irritating products, as well as causing delay in seeking suitable dermatological care, increasing the risk of continuation. In addition, data on acne efficacy is limited and information presented by companies is much more based on in vitro research than in randomized controlled trials of finished products.98
Acne cosmeceuticals include cleansing agents for oily or sensitive skin, sebaceous secretion regulators, anti-inflammatory drugs, moisturizers and sunscreens (useful for preventing post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation). Clinical data on retinoids retinol, retinaldehyde, retinyl ester, adapalene 0.1%, niacinamide (active form, amide, niacin or nicotinic acid or vitamin B3) and glycolic acid in concentrations of 5 to 20% indicate that they may be useful in the initial, mild to moderate forms of acne, particularly comedonal and accompanied by increased seborrhea. They are not superior to medicines for these forms and there is no data for severe acne.99 Niacinamide may be useful for antimicrobial, sebostatic, anti-inflammatory effects, inhibition of melanosome transfer, increased synthesis of ceramides, inhibition of nitric oxide and consequent changes in capillary permeability.100
As some anti-acne agents may cause skin dryness, erythema and discomfort, moisturizers and cleansing agents (preferably soap-free and near-skin pH) are recommended as an essential part of the therapeutic regimen in AFA.7 It is necessary to add photo-protection with non-comedogenic products capable of also providing comfort and hydration. In certain climatic conditions the use of moisturizer may be crucial for adherence to treatment, counteracting dryness and improving the barrier function of the stratum corneum.97
Glycolic acid is the alpha-hydroxy acid most used in the treatment of acne and hyperpigmentation, as it quickly crosses the stratum corneum, reaches the lower layers of the epidermis and the hair follicles reducing the cohesion between the keratinocytes. It is considered useful in reducing the size of follicular ostia and in removing comedones.101 A topical combination containing 10.4% L-lactic acid, 2% salicylic acid and alpha-hydroxy acid/retinoate conjugate (ethyl lactyl retinoate) was used in the topical treatment of females of ages 20 to 58. After 4 weeks, improvement was achieved, which remained continuous and cumulative in the eighth week.102
A formulation containing 0.1% retinaldehyde and 6% glycolic acid was studied for concomitant use with other acne treatments (except retinoids) and has been shown to be tolerable. Authors commented on the possibility of using this formulation as monotherapy in mild to moderate acne.103
Among cosmetics, corrective makeup and camouflage are useful and should be part of the therapeutic regimen as they improve the quality of life, contribute to sun protection and reduce the habit of inconsistency, very common in females. Obvious facial injuries are a very important problem for women. Well-targeted use of cosmeceuticals and cosmetics can benefit drug treatment by reducing side effects, reducing the need for topical antibiotics, and improving adherence to the therapeutic regimen.97,104
Mechanical proceduresIntralesional infiltration with corticosteroid: The corticosteroid of choice for this minimally invasive procedure is triamcinolone acetonide. It is indicated in nodulocystic acne, in a concentration of 2.5mg/mL, diluted in distilled water, in single application, with improvement in 48 to 72 hours. In the presence of multiple lesions, 5mg per application should not be exceeded to avoid systemic absorption.105 It is useful in the treatment of inflammatory nodules, even during the use of oral isotretinoin, since it accelerates regression and relieves pain rapidly in these lesions. It is also indicated in the approach of hypertrophic and keloid scars, with total or partial regression.66,106
Manual extraction of comedones: Removal of comedones, particularly open ones, may be useful by unclogging the follicular opening, facilitating the penetration of topical keratolytic products and contributing to the reduction of inflammation. In addition, it provides a positive impact on the quality of life, prevents the manipulation of the lesions in an inadequate way by the patient and/or laymen.66
Eletrocauterization of macro-comedones: The electrocautery of closed macro-comedones should be performed with great care not to reach excessive depth and cause scarring. It is useful since macro-comedones frequently evolve to inflammatory lesions. In addition, it avoids manipulation that causes exulcerations and inflammation.66
Draining of cysts and abscesses: It is a necessary procedure when there is fluctuation in these lesions, associated with the use of oral antibiotics, because it reduces the period of evolution and the scarring development.
Microdermabrasion: Microdermabrasion is a very superficial exfoliation method equivalent to a superficial peeling. It is based on the blasting of aluminum crystals until the appearance of mild erythema. After 2 to 3 days there is a fine peeling. The advantage over chemical peels is lack of burning, but the result may be poorer. It is most indicated in the preparation of the skin for the treatment of superficial atrophic scars. It is a simple, safe procedure and when carried out serially in several weekly sessions can induce reorganization and increase the density of dermal collagen.66,107
Chemical peels, lights and lasersThe superficial chemical peels have keratolytic action, causing superficial exfoliation due to its epidermal effects that are useful for comedonal and mild inflammatory forms. The most commonly used agents in the treatment of active acne are Jessner’s solution, 10% trichloroacetic acid (TCA) or 20% in aqueous solution, 30% salicylic in hydro-alcoholic solution or polyethylene glycol, 70% glycolic or other gel concentrations of natrosol, with partially buffered pH and 50% pyruvic acid. Salicylic and pyruvic acids have demonstrated a significant reduction in sebum content in the skin with acne through sebummetry.108 Several comparative studies have shown similar efficacy among the agents, with varying differences in tolerability.109 All can cause burning, erythema and desquamation after 3 to 5 days, lasting from 7 to 15 days. Unpredictable immediate reactions may occur, particularly with glycolic acid, which requires more care and observation of symptoms and signs until their removal. Such reactions include edema, vesiculation and undesirable bleaching due to epidermolysis. In this situation, immediate neutralization with 10% sodium bicarbonate in aqueous solution and removal of the agent should be performed. In general, they are safe procedures, without late complications; except when exaggerated, unpredictable immediate reactions occur that may cause post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation.
The average peels are performed with the combination of a keratolytic agent - Jessner’s solution (no removal) or 70% glycolic acid (removed as soon as there is mild burning or the appearance of erythema) - and TCA 35% in aqueous solution applied immediately after. They are indicated for the treatment of superficial atrophic scars in isolated semi-annual applications or associated with other procedures at different times, particularly when they are deep.106,110,111 In this situation, the peel acts as a preparation of the skin, making its surface more homogeneous.
The application of blue or red light emitting diodes (LEDs) has an anti-inflammatory effect faster than topical and/or systemic treatments. One study showed that this effect was similar to salicylic acid peel. The associated lights in the early stages of treatment improved inflammation and adhesion. No adverse event has been recorded.112 Photodynamic Therapy (PDT), as it is better known, has been proposed as a therapeutic option for acne, although with many doubts and scanty evidence.113
A review of randomized, controlled studies of light-based therapies for acne treatment concluded that none of the studies demonstrated efficacy; it is necessary to carry out well-designed studies that employ standardized outcome measures as well as comparison with usual drug treatments.114
At the moment there is no laser technology whose target is the sebaceous gland and that can destroy it, leading to healing. Two suggestions have been discussed. One associates an integrated cooling and vacuum system applied to the skin followed by the application of 3 to 4 pulses of the 1540-nm medium-erbium: glass infrared laser. An open, uncontrolled study including 12 patients with mild to moderate acne used this method in 4 to 6 sessions, with a 2-week interval. The improvement scores were 3.6 and 2.0, on a scale of 0 to 4, after one and 3 months of the last session, without adverse events.115 Another recently developed method is the use of a suspension of inert gold micro-particles with silica center applied with 8-minute massage on the face followed by 800nm laser application. There are 3 sessions, with intervals of 2 weeks. There are reports of improvement of up to 61% of inflammatory lesions.116
ScarsAcute atrophic acne scars can be treated with minimally invasive procedures such as medium chemical peels, hyaluronic acid and L-poly-lactic acid fillers, and non-ablative radiofrequency.117 The most severe, which may be persistent, have a negative impact on the quality of life and pose a therapeutic challenge. The treatment is always prolonged and requires an association of techniques, including surgical removal of areas with intense atrophy, in several sessions.117-119 The most invasive procedures include: sub-incision, punch lift, dermabrasion, fractional CO2 laser or Erbium: Yag, ablative or non-ablative, microneedling, and radiofrequency, among others. The most commonly mentioned are the medium peels, various types of lasers and, more recently, microneedling.109,118-121 Studies with histological evaluation after fractionated CO2 laser treatment showed thickening of the epidermis, disappearance of degenerated elastic fibers, increased elastic fiber density and dermal collagen.119,120 These effects, in addition to treating scars, improve the general appearance of the skin and the signs of photo-aging, constituting interesting results for adult females. The combination of techniques is the most effective option for acne scars. A retrospective, non-blind, uncontrolled study evaluated in 114 patients the results of the combination, under tumescent anesthesia, in a single session, of 20% TCA superficial peel, extensive sub-incision and fractionated CO2 laser. There was improvement of 2.9 on a scale of 1 to 4 and few complications; 90% of the patients were satisfied.122 A recent systematic review concluded that there is no evidence of high quality for the various interventions proposed for the treatment of acne scars due to poor methodology, lack of statistical power, lack of standardization of efficacy data and variables evaluated before the interventions. There is moderate evidence for fillers, but there is a lack of studies with prolonged follow-up (the largest was 48 weeks) and comparative with placebo or false intervention. This review was not able to establish any intervention as a first line for the treatment of acne scars.123
Maintenance treatmentMaintenance therapy is needed to minimize the likelihood of relapse after treatment, since acne recurrences are common. Factors such as efficacy, tolerability and adherence should be taken into account when assessing the duration of maintenance therapy. According to an European review, 15 or 20% azelaic acid, 0.025% or 0.05% tretinoin and 0.1% adapalene are recommended as maintenance therapy in AFA.7
Quality of LifeThe term quality of life (QoL) can be characterized, in a subjective way, as the patient’s perception about their illness and treatment, whereas in the technical concept it covers a series of components related to mental health, physical, functional and social dimensions. In dermatological diseases, studies suggest that psychometric tools may help the physician better choose the therapeutic proposal and detect patients psychologically affected, even with a clinical condition considered to be mild. The development of indicators, instruments or questionnaires is based on evidence that there is disagreement between the evaluation of the physician or health professional and that of the patient regarding the severity of the disease and treatment success, as well as different responses to the established therapy and different levels of satisfaction between patients with the same clinical condition.124
Studies related to acne point to a negative influence on quality of life, including the presence of signs and symptoms of depression and anxiety, such as anger and low self-esteem.125-127 The use of disease-specific questionnaires, such as Quality of Life in Acne (Acne-QoL), already translated and validated for Brazilian Portuguese, quantifies the impact of acne on quality of life. 128-130
The literature shows that the impact on quality of life does not always correlate with the severity of acne. In some cases, females with mild clinical conditions have a high impact on quality of life.126 Studies have also shown that the psychological impact of acne appears to affect more females than males.131 In any case, the physician’s attention, good relationship with the patient and adequate treatment, topical and/or systemic, although not completely effective demonstrates a positive impact on quality of life.53
ConclusionAFA has been considered a particular subtype of acne, distinct from acne vulgaris or adolescent acne, not only for differences in clinical status and etiopathogenesis, but also for its chronicity, which may last until the postmenopausal period. Some characteristics such as more sensitive and less oily skin, and multiple etiopathogenic factors, such as new work rate in women’s lives, stress, sleep disorders, dietary supplements and certain types of contraceptive methods make management more complex. Recent findings on its chronicity, involving TLR stimulation, demonstrate that control of the innate immune response has contributed to understanding the mechanism of action of the drugs used in its treatment.
For all these issues, AFA is a challenge in clinical practices and should be further understood.
Financial support: None.
Conflict of interest: Dr. Samanta Nunes is a medical consultant at Bayer.
